Since I can't decide, I figured I'd let you guys. I didn't want to clutter my original map thread with "First one ftw" statements, so I made a new thread.

So, which bunker texture do you like better?

The first one?
Bunker 1, pic 1 (http://www.unc.edu/~alricha5/dodpics/dod_strand_bunker10000.jpg)
Bunker 1, pic 2 (http://www.unc.edu/~alricha5/dodpics/dod_strand_bunker10001.jpg)
Bunker 1, pic 3 (http://www.unc.edu/~alricha5/dodpics/dod_strand_bunker10002.jpg)

Or the second one?
Bunker 2, pic 1 (http://www.unc.edu/~alricha5/dodpics/dod_strand_bunker20003.jpg)
Bunker 2, pic 2 (http://www.unc.edu/~alricha5/dodpics/dod_strand_bunker20004.jpg)
Bunker 2, pic 3 (http://www.unc.edu/~alricha5/dodpics/dod_strand_bunker20005.jpg)

I would have to say the first one by far. The second is pretty ugly.

I like both, but I'd pick the first one. For historical accuracy. Like in this pic:

http://www.dday-overlord.com/img/normatoday/plag/omaha/photos_omaha_beach_bunker_ruquet.jpg

It's a very bad habit to try to mimic pictures that are taken nowadays because you have to take into consideration that back then, bunkers and the like were either made in WW1 a few years back or brand new, so they didn't look as wasted as some pictures show today.

Originally posted by Dash
It's a very bad habit to try to mimic pictures that are taken nowadays because you have to take into consideration that back then, bunkers and the like were either made in WW1 a few years back or brand new, so they didn't look as wasted as some pictures show today.
good point.

They're both too similar to me for it to even make a difference. I'd be happy with either, but if I had to choose, I'd say the first one for clarity's sake.

Originally posted by Dash
It's a very bad habit to try to mimic pictures that are taken nowadays because you have to take into consideration that back then, bunkers and the like were either made in WW1 a few years back or brand new, so they didn't look as wasted as some pictures show today.
no, but the cement/mortar lines were the same. Take away the years of dirt and it's pretty unchanged.

First one. Second one looks weird with the vertical lines.